
Good, bad, or ugly
There are several ways of looking at Hong Kong’s seventh successive Asian Rugby Emirates Men’s Championship triumph – as a celebration of strength in depth, as a sad indictment of the game in the region, or as a serious cause for concern when it comes to the city’s own ambitions.
A third-string made up of senior players needing minutes, club players and those with heady ambitions of being ready for the 2031 World Cup push brushed aside South Korea with relative ease last Sunday.
The 45-9 scoreline may not have been as lopsided as the 70-22 hammering Hong Kong handed out in Incheon last year, or the 67-7 one at Football Club in 2024, but it was no less emphatic.
From Hong Kong’s perspective, the past month has seen 18 players blooded as full internationals and sent back to their clubs with the message to be ready for 2027 and beyond.
Nigel Hotham, who led a Hong Kong coaching team also pulled from the sidelines, was at least realistic enough to know where most of the squad ranked in the pecking order.
“We had a team talk this morning and I said [to the players], ‘everyone’s got a reason to bring your A game’,” Hotham said immediately afterwards. “Some of these guys it’s just to say, look at me, I’m a club player but I’ve stood up to a Test match.
“The hope is that those club players go back and lift the level of the club, so it actually helps the level of Hong Kong rugby and the depth of the representative teams. I really cross my fingers that next year that someone who’s on a bigger pay scale decides we go in the ARC again.”
Quite what sort of state South Korean rugby is in, is anyone’s guess, but it doesn’t look good. The 23 players who took part last weekend included just four from the 2025 loss, and four who were recalled after the trouncing they experienced in 2024.
Sri Lanka, meanwhile, almost pulled off an upset against Hong Kong, only to have to forfeit this weekend’s game against Korea because they could not get their act together over the necessary visas.
With Japan decades ahead of everyone else in Asia, South Korea should be Hong Kong’s biggest rivals at this level.
As it is, the chasm that exists between Hong Kong and South Korea is mirrored in the one that exists between Japan and Hong Kong, and neither will be closed unless significant changes are made.
In that, South Korea are on their own, as are Hong Kong, but there can be no argument about the need for action in the domestic game in both.
Hong Kong China Rugby bosses wasted the most recent opportunity to improve standards by opting against having a team play in Japan’s lower divisions.
There is a belief among some that they can be raised within the city’s six-team premiership. But unless clubs are going to suddenly start importing All Blacks and Springboks in need of a paid holiday, all that will grow is the gap.
Of course, none of this should diminish the achievement of the 23 men who took to the Football Club pitch last weekend. Whatever direction their careers take from now on, they will forever be international rugby players, Asian champions and part of the city’s sporting history.
Washington Sentinels quarterback Shane Falco, aka Keanu Reeves, perhaps said it best: “Pain heals, chicks dig scars, glory lasts forever.”
|